Home › ED medications
Troubleshooting

ED Pills Not Working? What to Check Before You Switch Medication or Provider

A tablet that fails is often a timing, dose or health-cause problem. The labels and studies show what to check first and what second-line options exist.

By Men's Health Insider editorial teamUpdated

The short version

  • Little or no response to a PDE5 inhibitor affects an estimated 30% to 40% of men, and second-line options exist.1
  • Every label requires sexual stimulation, and a high-fat meal delays sildenafil and avanafil absorption.234
  • Doses can be raised or lowered within each label's range; in a 532-man sildenafil trial, higher doses scored better.5
  • Testosterone gel helped nonresponders only when baseline total testosterone was 3 ng/mL or below (TADTEST, 173 men).6
  • Nearly half of men stop PDE5 tablets within a year, so telling the prescriber matters.7

When an ED pill seems to do nothing, the cause is usually one of four things: how it was taken, the dose, another health factor, or a pill that is not what it claims to be. Labels for all four tablets say sexual stimulation is required for a response, that a high-fat meal can delay sildenafil and avanafil, and that the dose can be raised or lowered after the first try.234 A systematic review puts the share of men with little or no response to a PDE5 inhibitor at 30% to 40%, and several second-line options exist for them.1

This guide goes through the checks in the order a prescriber would, then what the evidence says about switching drugs, adding treatments and changing providers. It does not replace that visit, and it is not a reason to take more than the label allows.

Is the pill being taken the way the label says?

Start here, because it is the cheapest fix. The four tablets differ in timing, and mixing up the rules is common when someone switches brands.

CheckSildenafil (Viagra)Tadalafil (Cialis)VardenafilAvanafil (Stendra)
Usual starting dose50 mg210 mg as needed, or 2.5 mg once daily810 mg3100 mg4
Timing before sexual activityAbout 1 hour; 30 minutes to 4 hours allowed2Before anticipated activity; benefit up to 36 hours8About 60 minutes3As early as about 15 minutes4
FoodHigh-fat meal delays absorption (peak concentration about 60 minutes later, 29% lower)2With or without food8With or without food3High-fat meal delays absorption, 39% lower peak4
Dose range after first try25 to 100 mg25 to 20 mg as needed85 to 20 mg350 to 200 mg4
Maximum frequencyOnce per day2Once per day (as needed form)8Once per day3Once per day4

The vardenafil and avanafil labels state that sexual stimulation is required for a response, and the sildenafil label describes the same mechanism: the drug raises cGMP only after stimulation releases nitric oxide.342 A tablet does not produce an erection on its own, so a first attempt without arousal, or with heavy anxiety, can look like failure.

Could the dose be too low?

Often, and labels build in room to adjust. The sildenafil label says the dose may be raised to 100 mg or lowered to 25 mg based on effectiveness and toleration, tadalafil moves between 5 and 20 mg, vardenafil between 5 and 20 mg, and avanafil between 50 and 200 mg.2834 In the original sildenafil dose-response trial (532 men, 24 weeks), higher doses were linked to better erectile function scores, and in a second trial that escalated doses (329 men) 69% of attempts at intercourse were successful on sildenafil versus 22% on placebo.5 Those trials enrolled men with organic, psychogenic and mixed causes, so they show that dose matters rather than predicting any one man's result.

Raising the dose is a prescriber decision. Doses above the label maximum are not allowed, and some medicines (strong CYP3A4 inhibitors, for example) lower the ceiling.83

Does another health problem explain it?

Yes, sometimes, and it is why a second visit matters more than a stronger pill. Men with diabetes appear to respond less often than men without it, according to a 2023 narrative review, which lists injections, urethral alprostadil, vacuum devices and penile implants as options for men whose tablets fail.9 See the diabetes-specific trial data in our guide to the best ED medication for men with diabetes.

Low testosterone is another. In the TADTEST trial, 173 men aged 45 to 80 who had not responded to PDE5 inhibitors took tadalafil 10 mg daily and were then randomized to testosterone gel or placebo. Across the whole group, adding testosterone gave no extra benefit; the difference appeared only in men whose baseline total testosterone was 3 ng/mL or below.6 A 2019 review likewise found no trial in which androgen plus a PDE5 inhibitor beat the PDE5 inhibitor alone in the nonresponder trials it included.1 The AUA testosterone guideline covers who should be tested.10

Blood pressure drugs, mental health and stress also matter. Our page on ED medication for high blood pressure covers the first; for the second, a meta-analysis of 11 randomized trials (398 men) found men given psychotherapy plus sildenafil improved and were less likely to drop out than men given sildenafil alone.11 Counselling is an add-on, not a sign the problem is imagined.

Is it the pill itself?

If tablets came from a site that did not require a prescription, doubt the product before the dose. FDA keeps a list of sexual enhancement products found to contain hidden drug ingredients,12 and a 2011 study of products ordered from international online pharmacies found labeling and packaging problems in the samples it checked (a small study, so it shows the pattern, not today's market).13 Our guide on how online prescribing of Viagra should work lists the signals of a legitimate pharmacy. Counterfeit or contaminated tablets are also a safety problem, because the dose and ingredients are unknown.

What are the next steps if tablets still fail?

A prescriber has several moves before giving up on oral treatment:

Stopping is common. A meta-analysis of 22 studies (162,936 men, mean age 58.8) found a mean 4% monthly dropout from the first-generation tablets, almost 50% after a year, with partner-related problems and lack of efficacy leading the reasons and no single factor dominant.7 Stopping silently leaves a treatable problem untouched, so tell the prescriber.

Should the provider change, not the drug?

Sometimes. A telehealth service that only sends the same refill is not helping a man whose tablets fail. Look for a clinician who asks what was tried, when, at what dose and with what food, who reviews testosterone and heart or diabetes history, and who can discuss second-line options or refer to a urologist. The review of dropout above suggests the cause is rarely one thing, so a provider who asks only about the pill misses most of it.7

Seek urgent care for an erection lasting more than four hours, and stop the medicine and get help for sudden vision or hearing loss.82

Talk to a clinician. This article explains the evidence; it cannot tell you what is right for you. A licensed clinician who knows your health history and medications can.
Important safety information. PDE5 inhibitors (sildenafil, tadalafil, vardenafil) must not be taken with nitrates in any form, including nitroglycerin, or with guanylate cyclase stimulators such as riociguat, and need caution with alpha-blockers.2 The most common side effects are headache and flushing.2 An erection lasting more than four hours needs emergency care, and sudden loss of vision or hearing means stopping and getting medical help right away.8 Only a licensed clinician who knows your health history and medications should decide whether these are safe for you.

Frequently asked questions

Why are my ED pills not working?

Common reasons are timing, a high-fat meal with sildenafil or avanafil, no sexual stimulation, a dose that is too low, another health condition such as diabetes or low testosterone, or a product that is not genuine.

Can ED pills stop working over time?

The studies here do not show a tablet losing its effect on its own. Dropout is high, nearly 50% within a year in one meta-analysis, with lack of efficacy and partner problems among the main reasons. Changing health or medicines can also alter response.

What should I do if Viagra isn't working?

Check that it was taken about an hour before, on a not-too-heavy stomach, with arousal, no more than once a day. Then ask a prescriber about the 25 to 100 mg dose range, switching drugs, and checks for diabetes or testosterone.

How many times should I try an ED pill before switching?

The labels do not set a number of attempts. They allow dose changes based on effectiveness and tolerability, so the decision belongs to the prescriber who knows the doses already tried.

What are the options if ED medication fails completely?

Reviews list alprostadil injections or urethral suppositories, vacuum devices, penile implants, and for some men combination treatments or counselling, chosen with a clinician.

Related reading

Sources

  1. Munk NE, et al. Systematic review of oral combination therapy for erectile dysfunction when phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitor monotherapy fails. Sex Med Rev. 2019. PubMed 30711478.
  2. Pfizer. VIAGRA (sildenafil citrate) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  3. Lannett Company. Vardenafil hydrochloride tablets prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  4. Metuchen Pharmaceuticals. STENDRA (avanafil) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  5. Goldstein I, et al. Oral sildenafil in the treatment of erectile dysfunction. N Engl J Med. 1998. PubMed 9580646.
  6. Buvat J, et al. Hypogonadal men nonresponders to the PDE5 inhibitor tadalafil benefit from normalization of testosterone levels with a 1% hydroalcoholic testosterone gel in the treatment of erectile dysfunction (TADTEST study). J Sex Med. 2011. PubMed 20704642.
  7. Corona G, et al. First-generation phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors dropout: a comprehensive review and meta-analysis. Andrology. 2016. PubMed 27636710.
  8. Eli Lilly. CIALIS (tadalafil) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  9. Cayetano-Alcaraz AA, et al. The management of erectile dysfunction in men with diabetes mellitus unresponsive to phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors. Andrology. 2023. PubMed 35929992.
  10. Mulhall JP, et al. An open-label, uncontrolled dose-optimization study of sublingual apomorphine in erectile dysfunction. Clin Ther. 2001. PubMed 11558862.
  11. Melnik T, et al. The effectiveness of psychological interventions for the treatment of erectile dysfunction: systematic review and meta-analysis, including comparisons to sildenafil treatment, intracavernosal injection, and vacuum devices. J Sex Med. 2008. PubMed 18564156.
  12. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Weight Loss Product Notifications.
  13. Veronin M. Packaging and labeling of pharmaceutical products obtained from the internet. J Med Internet Res. 2011. PMID 21324833.